How pay-per-call MVA leads work
A pay-per-call MVA campaign routes inbound phone calls from motor vehicle accident victims directly to your firm's intake line. The supplier runs the upstream marketing — paid search, paid social, click-to-call ad units — and bills you only when a call connects and exceeds a duration threshold (typically 90–120 seconds). Calls under the threshold are unbilled.
The economics, side-by-side with form-fill
Pay-per-call MVA inquiries usually outperform form-fill on contact rate (the prospect is already on the line) and run comparable signed-case CPA when the threshold and intake are set up correctly.
| Metric | Pay-per-call | Form-fill (exclusive) |
|---|---|---|
| Unit price | $80–$250 per qualified call | $250–$500 per lead |
| Contact rate | ~100% (call is the contact) | 75–90% |
| Signed-case rate | 14–22% | 10–18% |
| Cost per signed case | $1,500–$2,800 | $1,800–$3,000 |
| Intake requirement | Live during call hours | Callback within minutes |
When pay-per-call wins
- You have a live intake floor with extended hours (7am–9pm at minimum) and bilingual coverage if you serve Spanish-speaking markets.
- You're tracking signed-case rate per channel and willing to optimize call routing on actual outcomes, not vanity metrics.
- You want a higher contact-rate floor than form-fill provides — particularly useful if your form-fill performance has degraded with privacy-platform shifts.
When form-fill is the better choice
- Your intake team's hours don't cover the geography's peak dial windows (e.g., a Florida market with a 9am–5pm intake floor will miss most evening accident inquiries).
- You want to call back at a controlled cadence using a tested script — see our intake-call script field note on the 6-to-14% lift from scripting the first 90 seconds.
- You prefer the data trail of a form submission (consent timestamp, IP, source URL, structured fields) over the lighter trail of a routed call.
What to put in the pay-per-call contract
- Duration threshold. 90 seconds is the industry floor. Negotiate 120 seconds if your intake screens fast and you don't want to pay for borderline calls.
- Geo and case-type filters. State-level routing at minimum; ZIP-level routing if available. Exclude case types you don't sign (e.g., commercial truck if your firm doesn't litigate them).
- Block-list windows. The right to dispute and credit calls that obviously fail criteria (spam, wrong-number transfers, prospects already represented).
- Concurrency caps. A maximum number of simultaneous calls — protects your intake from being overwhelmed during peak windows.
- TCPA documentation. The supplier should provide the publisher list, consent disclosures used in their ad creative, and the calling number's compliance status on demand.
How to evaluate a pay-per-call vendor
The questions worth asking before signing a PPC agreement:
- What's your blended signed-case CPA across active PI clients in the last 90 days?
- Which publishers are routing into the call flow? How do you handle blocklist additions?
- What's the average call duration on billed calls vs. all calls?
- Can I run a 14-day pilot with a hard spend cap before committing to a monthly minimum?
A vendor who can't produce a per-signed-case CPA number for at least one active client is optimizing for the wrong metric. That's the same red flag we covered in the programmatic-display field note — different channel, identical question.